Water Heater Repair & Replacement

Water Heater Services

Servicing gas, electric, and tankless water heaters throughout Madison Wisconsin Greater Area

Tired of Cold Showers?

Your home and business’ water heater is a necessity but you might not even notice you have one until it no longer works.

How many times have you turned on your shower or kitchen faucet and expected hot water but instead get blasted with frigid water? Having that happen can throw off your entire day. You find yourself scrolling through online reviews looking for the best plumber who can help you solve this problem before you’re late for work. We’ve all been there. Don’t get stuck in scrolling mode, call Benjamin Plumbing for your water heater repair or water heater replacement services.

Common Water Heater Problems

  • No Hot Water: Relight pilots, replace elements, or replace components for quick restoration.
  • Insufficient Hot Water: Flushing and part replacement may resolve the problem.
  • Leaking Tank: Investigate source of leak to verify tank is the problem. If so, usually a full replacement is necessary. Investigate replacement options.
  • Noisy Heater: Annual flushing removes sediment, quiets pops, and boosts efficiency.
    Rusty or Discolored Water: Flushing and anode rod replacement stop corrosion and improve quality.
  • Smelly Water: Chlorine treatment can flush bacteria for fresh, odor-free water. Anode rod replacement may resolve the problem
  • High Energy Bills: Cleaning and replacing faulty parts improve heating speed.

For all issues, contact us for a free diagnosis. We service all major brands and types, including tankless models, with same-day availability for emergencies. See more details in our Common Water Heater Problems and Fixes blog.

No Hot Water? Here’s What to Check

If your water suddenly isn’t heating up, you might be able to spot the issue. Before you call a plumber, there are a few simple things you can safely check at home.

  • Reset or reboot power & gas supply: Make sure your water heater has power. Turn the unit off and back on to help reset the system.
  • Pilot light or exhaust: For gas models, relight the pilot if it’s out and clear any snow or debris blocking the intake or exhaust termination.
  • Temperature setting: Ensure the thermostat is around 120°F.
  • Fixture check: The issue might be with one faucet, not the heater.

Get Hot Water Right Away with Plumbing Experts

If none of these quick checks restore your hot water, it’s time to call in the experts. Our licensed plumbers diagnose and repair all types of water heater issues — from worn-out heating elements to faulty thermostats or gas valves — and can advise when replacement is the most cost-effective option.

Water Heater Repair

Our expert technicians diagnose and fix common issues like leaks, thermostat failures, heating element problems, and sediment buildup quickly and affordably. Regular maintenance prevents breakdowns and extends your unit's lifespan.

Water Heater Replacement

Your home and business’ water heater is a necessity but you might not even notice you need a replacement until it no longer works.

How to know if you need a water heater replacement:

  1. If your water heater is around 10 years old, that is a good indicator that you will be needing a replacement soon. Don’t get stuck with a cold shower, be proactive! Investigate new high efficiency options.
  2. Rusty or brownish colored water is another indicator that your hot water heater may need to be repaired or replaced.
  3. Check on your water heater and listen for grumbling, popping, other noises coming from it, or water leaking. Both can be nuisances and costly in the end if they aren’t taken care of by a professional.

New Water Heater Installation

Benjamin Plumbing provides professional installation for new gas, electric, and tankless water heaters, ensuring proper sizing for your home's needs and efficient operation with minimal disruption. Our team helps you select the right model and connect it seamlessly to your plumbing systems. Energy-efficient options can reduce utility bills and provide reliable hot water for years.

How to Make Your Hot Water Last Longer

Running out of hot water too quickly? A few simple adjustments can help improve efficiency in your home giving you faster hot water and saving you money:

  • Remove sediment by flushing your water heater yearly.
  • Insulate your tank and pipes to help retain heat.
  • Adjusting the thermostat for the heater around 120°F balances comfort and energy savings while maintaining steady hot water.
  • Consider upgrading to a larger or tankless unit to prevent frequent run outs and boost efficiency.

Our team can help you maintain your existing system or recommend upgrades to ensure you always have enough hot water for your family’s needs.

FAQ

Your Friend in the Plumbing Business

Benjamin Plumbing has grown into one of the largest plumbing companies in Dane county. For over 63 years we have strived to have the best quality products and services to provide to our customers. When we receive your call about water heater problems, our elite team meets you at your home in a timely manner that works in your schedule.

If you suspect that your hot water heater may need repair or replacement look for the signs. Please visit our Scheduled Services so we can help you with any plumbing repair.

Don’t wait for cold showers or leaks to get worse. Whether you need repair, replacement, or a fresh install, our licensed experts are here to help. Visit our specials page for discounts on Water Heater Installation!